Payment Fraud and Phishing: A Cyber Checklist for Clinics

Scammers are targeting Ontario clinics with fake invoices and AI-written emails. Use this cybersecurity checklist to protect your practice and payments.

The most expensive email your clinic receives this year may look like an ordinary invoice from a vendor you already pay. In October, the Ontario Medical Association warned physicians that cyber scams targeting physicians and business owners increasingly rely on deception rather than hacking: fake vendors, hijacked email accounts and AI-written messages designed to get someone on your team to change a payment, share a password or click a link. Dental associations ran the same warning for dental offices.

Why This Is a Practice Management Problem

The Canadian Centre for Cyber Security describes social engineering as one of the most effective ways to compromise systems, often more successful than advanced technical attacks. It works because it targets people, not software. In a clinic, the people most likely to be targeted are the ones who handle payments, payroll, vendor accounts and patient communications.

The OMA highlights three scams in particular:

  • Business email compromise and invoice fraud. Attackers impersonate a trusted vendor or take over an email account to redirect payments. Greg Moshonas, vice-president of cybersecurity and foundational services at Ontario Health, flags this as a common tactic.
  • Credential theft and ransomware. Stolen logins are used to get into systems, steal data, disrupt operations and demand payment.
  • AI-enabled impersonation. Criminals use AI to write convincing emails or create deepfake voice messages and videos posing as executives, physicians, vendors or staff. University Health Network recently warned about fake social media videos and ads misusing its physicians’ and nurses’ identities to promote health products.

How an Attack Usually Unfolds

Ariane Siegel, general counsel and chief privacy officer at OntarioMD, describes a familiar pattern. It often starts with a realistic email that appears to come from a vendor, colleague, physician or lab. Once someone clicks a link or enters a password, the attacker can read real email threads, learn how the clinic works, and send further requests that look entirely routine. As Siegel puts it, “Scams tend to have a little more information about you.”

That is why the “change of banking details” email is so dangerous. By the time it arrives, it may reference a real invoice, a real contact and a real payment schedule.

The Warning Signs

The OMA lists the signals staff should stop and question:

  • Urgent or threatening language designed to rush a decision
  • Requests for passwords, password resets, multi-factor authentication approvals, patient information or remote desktop access
  • Requests to change payments, payroll or banking details, or to install software
  • Unexpected links or attachments
  • Contact through an unusual channel or from someone unfamiliar
  • Requests to skip normal approval steps
  • Spelling mistakes or unusual wording and tone

The Canadian Dental Association’s phishing guidance for dental practices adds a simple habit: hover over a link to see where it really leads before clicking, and never reply to a suspicious email with personal information.

Five Payment Controls Every Clinic Should Have

The OMA’s core advice is to pause and verify any suspicious request through a trusted, independent channel. For the money side of a practice, that translates into a few firm rules:

  1. Never change banking details from an email. Any request to change a vendor’s or employee’s banking information is confirmed by phone, using a number you already have on file, not one in the email.
  2. Use two people for payee changes. One person enters a new or changed payee, and a second person approves it.
  3. Treat payroll changes the same way. A staff member asking by email to redirect their pay is verified in person or by a known phone number.
  4. Turn on multi-factor authentication for email, banking, payroll and billing accounts.
  5. Make it safe to ask. Staff should never be criticized for double-checking a request from a physician or owner. The OMA stresses a culture where employees feel comfortable reporting concerns and verifying unusual requests.

The OMA Self-Audit Checklist

The OMA also published a cybersecurity self-audit checklist that works for both medical and dental offices. In summary:

Accountability and oversight

  • We know who is responsible for privacy and cybersecurity, including passwords, software updates, audits and incident response.
  • We have up-to-date contact information for key staff and vendors in case systems go down.

Vendors and third-party support

  • We know which security responsibilities are ours and which belong to our vendors.
  • We have reviewed safeguards, backups and weak points with our vendors.

Training and awareness

  • All physicians and staff complete annual privacy and cybersecurity training.
  • Staff are regularly reminded how to recognize and report suspicious emails, messages and requests.

Technical safeguards

  • Strong passwords and multi-factor authentication are enabled across our systems.
  • Devices and software are regularly updated and patched.
  • We keep and regularly test secure backups of critical data.

Recovery and incident response

  • We know how long it would take to restore our systems after an outage or ransomware attack.
  • We have a documented incident response plan, including who to contact.
  • Key contact information is accessible even if our systems are down.

If you cannot tick a box, that is your starting point.

How MAP Can Help

Payment fraud sits where finance, HR and IT meet, which is often where nobody owns it. MAP’s Accounting and Finance, HR Management and Digital Integration teams help Ontario physician and dental practices put payment controls, staff training and vendor processes in place. Learn more at maphcm.com.